MakerBot Print is our newest print-prepration software, which supports native CAD files and STL assemblies,
allows you to interact with all your printers via the Cloud, and many other exciting new features.

Download Now

Report as inappropriate

Sounds like the Oscar should be a good 'first' pinhole camera then (Though I also like the looks of the ACME series, a 4x5 OSCAR would be nice too).
Matterhackers describes their standard PLA ($27) as Opaque, (figures that the first two choices on your list are currently out of stock, and the #2 is an import from the UK).

I still have a few fractional KG cardboard spools of some 'surplus' black PLA I bought on Ebay a few years back at a super cheap price when I first built my Repstrap. The stuff passes your Opaque test object with flying colors, it's the blackest black PLA I've ever seen. I have no idea who made it or where I could buy more. (CTTOI I think there might have been a brand name on the box, if I still have the original box .... )